Poet and historian why they different

Philosophy and history have only developed as a result of the "great passport of poetry. According to Poetics 8, human lives do not exhibit such an order. It should imitate an action evoking pity and fear.

For the poet, this means the result will be a product of fiction, and for the historian, a product of non-fiction. Showing the superiority of poetry to history and philosophy Sidney says that while the philosopher teaches by precept alone, and the historian by example alone, the poet conduces most to virtue because he employes both precept and example.

Discovery must occur within the plot. He adjusts what he hears to his existing store of phrases, typical scenes, and themes, and he tends to replace what is unfamiliar to him with something he already knows, or to expand it by adding familiar material that it happens to lack. The mixture of academia, be-bop jazz, the liberating free verse of William Carlos Williams, and the influence of budding author Jack Kerouac who coined the term "Beat Generation" in at a meeting with Allen Ginsberg, Herbert Huncke, and William S.

Ancient Greek literature

Thucydides's book History of the Peloponnesian War greatly influenced later writers and historians, including the author of the book of Acts of the Apostles and the Byzantine Era historian Procopius of Caesarea.

Indeed, several professors that I have either had or was a Teaching Assistant for have used novels instead of academic works to discuss political events.

The longest to have survived purports to be by Herodotus himself; but it is quite devoid of objective truth.

Among them are limericksmany comics and thrillers. History deals with the particular alone, philosophy with the general alone, poetry deals with both the particular and the general the universal. It seems to me far more productive to ask how lyrics in songs relate to musical information, and how poems relate to the silences cultural and actual that surround them, and to recognize that lyrics and poetry, while different genres with different forces and imperatives, have both more and less in common than we might think, and are endeavors of equal value.

See also Greek literature: He draws a very clear line between what is fiction and what is factual and thus historical.

Many musical artists present their song lyrics as poetry. Carlinotes — leans toward Armstrong but notes differences between the use of the term in Poetics 9 and Poets were often dramatists who wrote for choirs, or courtly muses who entertained regional kings.

Now we are going one step further to become completely ad-free.

The historian as poet or the poet as historian—using historical fiction in historical scholarship

Yet the process was presumably carried much further in the making of the monumental Iliad, consisting of more than 16, verses, which would take four or five long evenings, and perhaps more, to perform.

I mean that he might investigate what is universal in them in the following way, e. Essentially, he is talking about epics and the way the author forms the story based on true facts and fiction.

As Poetics 9 puts it: Beat poets and their works fostered a new era of appreciation and study of poetry. Herodotus reports a Sicilian tradition about the coincidence of the two battles viwithin an extended nar- rative about the initial actions of the Hellenic League, which included sending messengers to Argos, Sicily, Corcyra, and Crete vi — In this way, works of fiction can also be primary source accounts of the events at hand.

These musical artists use their considerable skill and sensitivity to design music that moves around and with the poems, never overloading them with musical information or tormenting them into overly strained forms to serve a musical structure, two of the most noticeable qualities of failed musical-poetic collaborations.

Among the earliest Greek philosophers were the three so-called " Milesian philosophers ": Although the genre was popular, only one complete example of a satyr play has survived: Such relatively short songs must have provided the backbone of the tradition inherited by Homer, and his portraits of Demodocus and Phemius are likely to be accurate in this respect.

He is thus made virtuous. The lost second part addressed comedy. The poet improves upon history, he gives examples of vice and virtue for human imitation; he makes virtue succeed and vice fail, and this history can but seldom do.

The Greeks and the Romans regarded the poet as maker or creator. At the same time, the struggle faced by the historian writing a narrative is to remain true to the facts and not being primarily concerned with evoking specific emotions among its readership.

Poets shared an interest in metaphysical subjects and practiced similar means of investigating them.

Universal means the kinds of things that it suits a certain kind of person to say or do in terms of what is likely or necessary: In many ways, the Elizabethan era more closely resembled the expressionism of the Ancient Greeks than the Sicilian and Italian Renaissance schools from which it derived its base poetry.

On the other hand, the historian deals with particular instances, with vices and virtues so mingled together in the same personage that the reader can find no pattern to imitate. By [Wians-Polansky] ChLockwood-proof [version date.

Find an answer to your question Why did the writings of the poet Virgil and the historian Livy focus on the rise and fall of Roman power? 1. Log in Join now 1. Log in Join now Middle School They wanted to arouse patriotism and restore traditional roman virtues.

Why do the planets have different colours? The answer is that the planets are different colors because they are made of different materials. Planets have the colours that they have because of what they are made of and how their surfaces or atmospheres reflect and absorb sunlight.

Although the existence of Persians does not by itself prove the claim that Aristotle has a place for history in his Poetics, at the least it presents an actual example of a poet working from τὰ γενόμενα to construct a poetic universal, one which is oriented by the poet’s rather than the historian’s function.

Find an answer to your question why did the writings of the poet Virgil and the historian Livy focus on the rise and fall of roman power. Dec 06,  · The Difference Between Poetry and Song Lyrics. but a desire for the words they write to be taken seriously.

How does Sidney define poetry? How does he establish its superiority over Philosophy and History?

It is certainly true that poems are taught (for better or worse) in classrooms and made a part of the canon of literature, whereas songs, especially popular ones, usually are not. while different genres with different forces and.

Poets and historians may undergo the same processes, but how they handle the subject, the contents, and method will lead to the separate results. For the poet, this means the result will be a product of fiction, and for the historian, a product of non-fiction.

Poet and historian why they different
Rated 3/5 based on 49 review
Aristotle on the (alleged) inferiority of history to poetry | Thornton Lockwood - thesanfranista.com